Round 2, Pairing 16: "Eternal Harvest (FFIX)" vs. "Matoya's Cave (FFI NES)"

[Dave]

Yet another pairing, and you should know where to vote (http://www.squareenixmusic.com/uematsu.php) by now. :) Please comment, and tell me if I've messed up somewhere. :p

[Neo Locke]

Eternal Harvest is pretty good, but dreadfully short to consider worthwhile.

Matoya's Cave is a classic, and although slightly out of date sound-wise, is still one of the most enjoyable melodies I know

Vote.

[TheShroud13]

I don't particularly care for either, but "Matoya's" is the more Uematsuey of the melodies, so it gets my vote.

[Aryires]

Old-school Uematsu plainly rocks! Vote for Matoya's Cave.

[Don]

Matoya's Cave gets my vote. Despite Eternal Harvest being very catchy, Matoya's Cave wins out over it because of its beautiful melody.

[Solartide]

Matoya wins cause of the good ol solo instrument thing

[insertnamehere]

Just like shroud i didn't care much for either but ill stick with matoya's cave

[Resk]

I'm going to go with......... Eternal Harvest I think.

[Brittany]

I like Eternal Harvest, but I love Matoya's Cave. It has one of my favorite melodies and it always manages to put a smile on my face when I hear it. I hope it gets really far in this contest.

[Dave]

I voted for "Matoya's Cave," and simply because it never ever grows old. Its unique atmosphere has managed to captivate me every time I've heard it. :) (About 100 times :p).

[Dave]

Matoya's Cave (FFI NES) 70.00 % (21)
Eternal Harvest (FFIX) 30.00 % (9)

/sigh. Only 30 votes? This means war.

[Black Mamba]

*thanks god Matoya's Cave made in through in his absense*

[Chris]

Go "Matoya's Cave". Everyone loves you.

I like the piano arrangement of "Eternal Harvest", but the OST version wasn't a major highlight.